Still not writing. Found a heart for the Tiki book, though. It fits all the needs; it interests me, it offers some good challenges in story-telling, it connects to the world and theme in a way that integrates all three legs of this tripod. (Character, world, plot, that is.)
But it is also something I am probably not the right writer for.
When I dreamed up my protagonist, Rick was clearly an everyman, a stock hero protagonist type (not to be confused with Hiro Protagonist from Snowcrash). I toyed with the idea of making him protean; that others would read things on to him. Like the protagonist of a Bethesda game, who every single faction views as the perfect representative of all their faction stands for. Generally on first meeting.
There's this concept of the blank slate character, the Audience Surrogate. It is argued in game circles now but it goes back to fiction and the theory is that specifying as little as possible makes it easier for the reader to project themselves onto that character. This also became a go-to argument for why, somehow, the hero always ended up looking the same.
I don't believe it worked out like that in practice. I think the cis white make protagonist survives not because he represents a majority audience but because he is comfortably normal. He fades into the background like the word "said."
(Not a place for that lecture, but inexperienced writers reach for screamed, shrilled, cried, hooted, hissed until their dialogue sounds like it is happening at a zoo. Just use "said." It vanishes, like "a" or "the.")
In fact, so powerful is this default (so invisible, rather) I think it is actually bad advice to write your female, gay, asian, whatever character without keeping in mind they live in a world that probably notices -- one that also makes assumptions about the prevalence of cis white male as the "average human." (Just talk to a woman about the design of seat belts.)
If you leave that interaction out, you risk, like the old joke about the surgeon who can't operate on their own son, the brain of the reader going back to the default.
You also leave out story potential, and this is why I'm in that position. Tiki is already in a potentially uncomfortable place with exoticism, cultural appropriations and colonial legacy. I knew this going into it. And I knew that because of how I was structuring the nove,l and some of the stories I was trying to tell in it, my ISO900 Standard Protagonist (Space Opera) was going to include the standard Mighty Whitey as part of the package (along with the "aw shucks" heroism and the two-fisted approach to problem-solving).
That's not the only reason I want not to do that. It's not just white guilt. Primarily, it is because this uneasy relationship -- between the origins of tiki and the consumerist paradise being built with that as an element -- is the potential theme I am looking at to drive the story. And it becomes theme, world-building, and conflict when it is also character.
If Rick isn't white, he can personally interrogate these conflicts. He can already be involved with some of the plots without needing to drop in with his TARDIS and decide to get involved out of the plain goodness of his heart or just because he's having a boring day.
And it presents a more interesting version of that protean conceit, as well; the internal culture conflict, with various factions declaring him "one of them," even to the extent he feels distinctly uncomfortable pressed into that role.
Of course there I am, adding masks and role play into a book again. One that already has tropes to contend with. I'm re-inventing all the things that were giving me trouble with the Athena Fox stories.